Mattheessen’s – Ice Cream, Cookies, Fudge
Mattheessen’s brings a dessert-shop concept associated with Key West to Nashville’s Second Avenue dining and entertainment district. Its menu centers on oversized cookies, ice cream, shakes, fudge, and key lime pie, offering a sweet stop a short walk from Broadway.
Giant Cookies and Ice Cream
Large cookies are a recognizable part of the Mattheessen’s brand. Their size and presentation help distinguish them from a conventional bakery case, turning a familiar dessert into something suited to sharing or enjoying as a special treat.
Ice cream and milkshakes provide another part of the menu, with frozen desserts appealing to visitors taking a break from the activity of downtown Nashville. Combining a cookie with ice cream is a natural option within this kind of dessert shop, although specific combinations should be checked against the current menu.
Fudge and Key Lime Pie
The shop also offers fudge and key lime pie, connecting its Nashville counter to the Florida Keys dessert traditions associated with the wider brand. Key lime pie, known for its tart citrus character and creamy filling, provides a contrast to richer chocolate and cookie selections.
Fudge adds another confectionery option for guests interested in traditional sweets or gifts to take away.
A Key West Connection in Music City
Mattheessen’s brand history reaches back to the Florida Keys, where it established a reputation for oversized sweets and classic desserts. The Nashville shop carries that identity into a setting shaped by tourism, restaurants, and nightlife.
Its Second Avenue location makes it convenient for visitors exploring downtown on foot. Instead of a full restaurant meal, Mattheessen’s offers an informal dessert-focused experience built around recognizable flavors and generously presented treats.