Amico’s New York Pizza Italian Restaurant

Fine Magazine Nashville - Local Business - Amico's New York Pizza Italian Restaurant

Amico’s New York Pizza Italian Restaurant is a family-run Nolensville restaurant serving hand-tossed pizza alongside pasta, baked dishes, sandwiches, calzones and stromboli. Anthony and Julie Amico opened the business in 2011, bringing a family restaurant background rooted in Brooklyn and Italian cooking to Middle Tennessee.

A family restaurant tradition

Anthony grew up in his parents’ New York restaurant, learning dough preparation and cooking from childhood. The family’s route took it from Sicily to Brooklyn and later South Florida before Tennessee. Amico’s was the first of Anthony and Julie’s restaurants to carry the family name.

That background is reflected in a menu extending beyond a pizza counter. Pizza remains central, but Italian-American pasta, chicken and eggplant dishes, salads and hot sandwiches provide several alternatives for a sit-down meal or takeout order.

New York pizza, slices and filled dough

Whole pizzas come in several sizes, with build-your-own toppings and a list of specialty combinations. The House Special brings together pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion and peppers, while other pizzas focus on vegetables, several meats or combinations of cheeses. A white Bianca pie and a fresh-tomato-sauce version provide different approaches to the topping structure.

Slices are part of the lunch offering, including combinations with salad or a drink. Calzones use ricotta, mozzarella and Romano, while stromboli come with a variety of fillings. Italian meats, meatballs, sausage and peppers, vegetables, or chicken and broccoli are among the options.

Pastas, sandwiches and group meals

The pasta selection includes baked ziti, stuffed shells, fettuccine Alfredo and penne with vodka sauce. Chicken and eggplant dishes form another section, and sandwiches include meatball, chicken or eggplant Parmigiana alongside an Italian cold-cut combination. The same menu can therefore serve a pizza order and several distinct Italian-style meals.

Starters include calamari, mozzarella wedges, garlic rolls and meatballs. Salads range from a garden selection to antipasto and Greek-style combinations, giving customers other ways to assemble a meal around the main dishes.

Amico’s also caters with pizzas, pasta trays, salads and Italian specialties for home, office and event gatherings. Online ordering connects its ordinary menu with pickup, while catering is arranged as a separate group service. The business’s defining combination remains a New York-style pizzeria and a broader family Italian restaurant.

Contact

Amico's New York Pizza Italian Restaurant